The widening gap between high and low incomes in the United States increasingly originates from education. Those with college degrees continue to earn substantially more than those without, yet fewer young people are pursuing higher education. At the same time, more employers are dropping degree requirements altogether, signaling a massive realignment in what skills and credentials actually matter.
Workers with a bachelor’s degree earn nearly twice as much as those with only a high school diploma.
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics
This triple crisis—declining college participation, stagnant secondary education, and the falling relevance of four-year degrees—threatens to fracture the workforce and the economy for generations. If we want to address inequality and equip the next generation for success, our investment must shift toward reforming high school before anything else.
Simultaneously, the traditional college pathway is losing both popularity and perceived value.
Undergraduate college enrollment has dropped by more than 1.2 million students over the past decade, a 6.4% decline.
National Student Clearinghouse
Families are questioning the return on investment (ROI) as tuition rises and as employers increasingly prioritize skills over degrees. In the meantime, our high schools—originally designed to serve a mid-20th-century workforce—have not evolved fast enough to prepare graduates for a world defined by AI, remote work, and self-employment.
Everyone seems to be concerned with college nowadays, but I truly believe the foundation of our education woes lies earlier… in high school.
High School: The Broken Bridge Between Childhood and Career
High school once functioned as a bridge—a space for learning, exploration, and preparation before adulthood. It provided the basics in literacy, numeracy, civics, and the sciences. Those who did not attend college could still find stable, long-term employment with on-the-job training and benefits. But that world no longer exists.
The modern economy is fragmented into contract, freelance, part-time, and gig-based work. Today’s workers must navigate taxes, business formation, proposal writing, client contracts, and digital self-promotion. Yet, these skills are rarely taught in high school. Students still memorize algebraic formulas and historical dates, but graduate unable to interpret a 1099 form, negotiate a freelance rate, or understand AI tools that dominate modern productivity suites.
Only 36% of U.S. fourth-graders performed at or above the proficient” level in mathematics, a continuing decline.
National Center for Education Statistics
Only 33% of fourth-graders were proficient in reading, while 37% performed below the basic level.
National Center for Education Statistics
Even basic academic skills—reading and math—are slipping. Combine that with the absence of real-world curriculum, and we’re not only failing students academically, we’re failing them economically.
When High School Fails, the Workforce Suffers
Employers now lament the gap between what high school graduates know and what the modern workforce requires. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce reports that over 9 million jobs remain unfilled, many of which don’t need a degree but do demand practical skills, professionalism, and critical thinking.
Our system’s inefficiency starts early. High school is supposed to produce adaptable young adults—but instead, it produces students with fragmented knowledge and limited workplace readiness. Students are trained to pass standardized tests, not to navigate life.
And when those same students opt out of college—either due to cost, skepticism, or necessity—they are left without the foundation needed to earn, grow, and contribute meaningfully in a competitive economy.
The college wage premium has widened to over 60%, meaning degree holders earn, on average, 60% more than those with only a high school diploma.
Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis
If we don’t prepare high school graduates for success—whether or not they attend college—we are dooming them to economic stagnation before they ever get started.
The Vanishing Safety of Youth
Looking back, I’m grateful I grew up in an era before smartphones and social media. My oldest friend from high school recently visited, and we laughed ourselves to tears recalling our teenage antics. We didn’t hurt anyone, but we definitely tested limits. Today’s teens don’t have that luxury.
Every moment is recordable, shareable, and permanent. A poor decision—one we might have learned from privately—can now become a viral post, a disciplinary hearing, or a scar on a digital footprint that follows someone into college admissions or job interviews.
Teens who use social media more than three hours a day face double the risk of poor mental health outcomes.
PubMed Central
This constant exposure doesn’t just impact mental health—it alters learning itself. Students live in a state of performative vigilance, curating identities and managing audiences instead of exploring ideas freely. Mistakes become permanent; risks become terrifying. High school, once a laboratory for trial and error, has become a stage with an unforgiving audience.
The U.S. Surgeon General warns that social media poses a profound risk of harm to adolescent mental health.
HHS.gov
The AI Literacy Problem
We’re also entering an era where artificial intelligence (AI) shapes nearly every profession—from marketing and law to sales and logistics. Yet most high school students (and many teachers) still misunderstand how AI works, what a prompt is, and why prompting determines the quality of the output.
AI literacy is no longer optional. Students must learn not only how to use AI tools ethically but also how to evaluate, prompt, and verify their outputs critically. Without this literacy, they risk being left behind in an AI-driven economy.
Rebuilding Secondary Education for the Modern World
To address these gaps, high school needs a fundamental overhaul. The reforms should focus on five priorities:
- A safe space to fail. Adolescents must have the right to make mistakes without those mistakes defining their futures. Education should provide room to learn privately, recover, and grow.
- Academic renewal. Reading and math proficiency rates must rise. Technology should enhance—not replace—foundational learning.
- Career and life readiness. Teach taxes, contracts, entrepreneurship, AI tools, proposal writing, and personal finance alongside core academics. Students should graduate capable of entering the workforce or starting a business.
- Digital and media literacy. Students must understand digital permanence, privacy, and the influence of algorithmic curation. They should learn how to manage their online reputations before they manage crises.
- Emotional and mental wellness. Social media pressures are real and growing. Schools must invest in mental-health programs, social-emotional learning, and resilience education.
If you don’t believe me, here’s a startling statistic for you:
77% of Gen Z job seekers have brought a parent to a job interview, and 53% said a parent has talked to hiring managers on their behalf.
Fortune
That statistic isn’t a sign of entitlement—it’s a signal that schools have failed to teach independence.
Conclusion
The income gap, college decline, and outdated high school curriculum are part of the same systemic failure: we haven’t updated our educational model for the realities of the modern world. We still teach as though college is the default destination and stability the guaranteed outcome. Neither is true anymore.
Businesses across every industry are struggling to find competent, adaptable help. Employers are now facing a generation of workers who may have degrees but lack the essential skills—communication, problem-solving, initiative, and digital literacy—that the workplace demands. As a result, many companies are increasingly turning to offshore talent and artificial intelligence to fill the gap. While these options may keep operations running, they don’t strengthen our workforce or rebuild local economies. Replacing human potential with automation or outsourcing is a symptom of failure, not progress.
If we want to close the income gap, restore opportunity, and prepare students for real life, we must start where every life begins: in high school. The stakes are too high to wait another generation.
Related Martech Zone Content
