
The National Security and Intelligence Review Agency is the Canadian body that reviews national security and intelligence activities for legality and reasonableness. It looks across departments, not only at one service. It reports to Parliament. It does not direct an operation and it does not prosecute.
One service inside its mandate is the Communications Security Establishment (CSE). The agency reviews that service. The service still runs its own operations, and the review comes after, or alongside, rather than as an order to collect.
What a Review Looks At
- Legality. Whether the activity was authorized.
- Reasonableness. Whether the activity was proportionate to the stated need.
- Across departments. More than one service can be in the same review.
Review Agency and an Intelligence Service
| Compared | The Review Agency | An Intelligence Service |
| Runs a collection | No | Yes |
| Judges legality after the fact | Yes | Not of itself |
| Reports to Parliament | Yes | Through ministers, on its own work |