The Evolution of Personalization: From Merge Tags to AI-Powered Experiences
What began as Dear {FirstName} has transformed into dynamic, predictive, generative, and increasingly immersive personalization.
Organizations with personalization programs supported at the C-level are 2x more likely to report high ROI.
Forrester
Sophisticated retailers and businesses now operate within a layered experience ecosystem: identity resolution, predictive decisioning, generative messaging, immersive AR/VR entry points, and AI-powered virtual assistants (VA) that accompany customers through every stage of their journey.
Table of Contents
The next frontier? Experiences that feel less like marketing and more like intelligent companionship. A system that understands your history, interprets your intent, adapts in real time, and engages with both relevance and empathy. The sophistication is already here. The responsibility lies with the brands that wield it.
The Humble Beginnings: Merge Tags and Static Segmentation
The story of personalization begins in the early days of email marketing. Campaigns were segmented by basic demographics—such as location or gender—and messages included merge tags to personalize them with a name, like Dear John. While this was a marked improvement over entirely mass-mailed blasts, the experience remained fundamentally impersonal. Each interaction was a template slotted with personal detail, lacking real context or timing.
The promise was evident: using someone’s name led to improved engagement. But the limits were quickly exposed. The messaging was not tailored to customer behavior, history, or lifecycle stage, and therefore, the overall experience remained generic. This was personalization by syntax, not by strategy.
Cookies and Clicks: Behavior-Driven Dynamic Content
With the rise of browser cookies, marketers gained the ability to track behavior across sessions. This was a pivotal shift. Retailers began to use browsing data to personalize in-session content, displaying recently viewed items, sending abandoned cart reminders, or dynamically updating homepage banners based on past interactions.
Rather than relying solely on who a customer was, marketing efforts now incorporated what the customer was doing. If someone views a specific product five times without purchasing it, they might see a discount on their next visit. Email campaigns could reflect that same product interest.
Despite these advancements, this approach was still largely reactive. Cookies are linked to devices, not people. So if a user switched from their phone to their laptop, the connection was lost. Real identity—and with it, deep personalization—remained out of reach.
Identity Resolution: From Anonymous to Known Journeys
Personalization reached a new milestone with identity resolution. This process involves linking disparate behavioral data across sessions, devices, and channels to a single customer profile. Through login information, email captures, loyalty programs, and backend customer relationship management systems (CRM/CDP), brands began to piece together fragmented data into cohesive profiles.
Identity intelligence allowed brands to move beyond session personalization to journey personalization. A known customer browsing a new category could be reminded of a recent in-store purchase. Someone flagged as lapsed could receive a win-back offer that referenced their favorite brand or product line.
Suddenly, personalization became not only deeper but also continuous. The customer journey was no longer a series of isolated episodes, but a story that unfolded over time and across touchpoints.
Predictive Analytics: Anticipating Churn, Affinities, Intent
The next transformation came from machine learning (ML). Predictive analytics enabled retailers to forecast customer behavior before it occurred. Agents, such as those developed at OpenINSIGHTS, can score customers based on churn risk, predict category interest, and even seasonality, to determine which products are most likely to be purchased next.
Retailers can now shift from reacting to anticipating by using deep behavioral and predictive insights to guide personalized engagement. Examples may include:
- A customer with declining engagement isn’t simply offered a generic discount; instead, their shopping habits, product preferences, and future value are analyzed to trigger timely, product-specific win-back campaigns.
- Seasonal shoppers are identified early and introduced to complementary categories before their typical buying window ends, increasing the likelihood of post-season engagement.
- Occasion-based buyers are encouraged to repurchase their favorite items through continuity strategies tied to usage cycles or key calendar moments.
- Even customers who have been inactive for extended periods can be reactivated through profit-led, product-focused outreach tailored to their original purchase behavior.
With these strategies, personalization becomes not just reactive but prescriptive, designed to expand category adoption, manage churn, and build long-term customer value.
These scores and forecasts weren’t just used for marketing. They informed customer service priorities, inventory decisions, and even merchandising strategy. Personalization was no longer just a communications function—it became an operational capability.
Generative AI: Scaling Personalized Messaging
Approximately two-thirds of decision-makers reported that generative AI helps their organization provide personalized experiences at scale.
Adobe via Forrester
Perhaps the most revolutionary shift came with the introduction of generative AI (GenAI). These systems could go beyond recommendations to generate content—such as emails, subject lines, SMS messages, push notifications, and more—tailored to each customer’s behavior, preferences, and brand affinity.
Instead of creating hundreds of versions of an email manually, marketers could supply their product catalog, campaign performance data, and brand tone guidelines to a generative AI model. The AI would then generate thousands of unique, contextually relevant messages in real-time.
A single customer might receive an email that says:
Hi, Jordan—summer’s heating up, and we noticed you’ve been hitting the trails. If you’re looking to cool things down, our new line of lightweight kayaks might be your next adventure. Explore options designed for first-timers, with easy rooftop transport and beginner bundles ready to go.
This kind of message is timely, personalized, branded, and adaptive. It’s generated based on browsing behavior, purchase history, current inventory, and real-time marketing performance.
The Personalization Tech Stack Comes Together
91% of retail IT leaders are prioritizing AI as the top technology to implement by 2026.
Gartner
These capabilities come to life through an integrated stack. Identity intelligence platforms aggregate and unify customer data. Predictive engines analyze patterns and assign scores. Generative AI platforms produce copy and creative content. Orchestration tools distribute these experiences across every channel, including email, web, app, SMS, and paid media.
Critically, these systems now operate as closed loops. Engagement data—such as opens, clicks, conversions, visits, and loyalty usage—feeds back into the predictive and generative layers, which adapt to optimize future outreach. Personalization is no longer just a decision engine; it’s a learning system.
The ROI of Personalization: Measurable and Strategic
Advanced personalization doesn’t just make customers feel known—it drives results. Experience leaders outperform competitors in revenue growth, customer retention, and operational efficiency.
Brands using real-time personalization strategies saw up to 4x improvement in customer lifetime value and email engagement.
Adobe
Yet the power of personalization also brings risk. Consumers now expect it, but not at the cost of privacy or dignity. And while today’s tools offer powerful capabilities, many implementations still fall short of delivering true value. Too often, personalization engines operate on shallow data, limited history, or static segments. The result is a system that pushes products rather than understands needs—a recommendation carousel that seems more self-serving than helpful.
This kind of algorithmic tunnel vision undermines trust. A customer browsing for travel accessories might be served high-margin suitcases repeatedly, even after purchasing one, while completely missing lower-cost but relevant items like power adapters or travel pillows. These misfires aren’t just technical bugs—they’re signs that the system is optimizing for the brand’s conversion goals rather than the customer’s journey.
When personalization becomes prescriptive instead of adaptive, it ceases to be helpful. It feels manipulative. It suggests the brand is listening only to what it wants to hear.
53% of customers report that personalization sometimes backfires—leading to post-purchase regret and reduced repeat buyers.
Gartner via DemandGen Report
This gap between intention and execution highlights a key lesson: relevance is not just a function of data, it’s a function of discernment. Effective personalization doesn’t just drive behavior—it demonstrates understanding. It meets customers where they are, with what they truly need, in the tone they prefer, at the time they’re most open.
To get there, organizations need more than a toolkit—they need a philosophy. They must architect personalization systems that strike a balance between optimization and empathy. That means curating product and content suggestions based on complete journeys, not just isolated clicks. It means suppressing messages when a customer has already resolved their need, and it means prioritizing long-term trust over short-term performance.
Brands that earn that trust will unlock not just higher engagement but deeper relationships. Because in the age of AI-powered personalization, the question is no longer whether you can reach the right customer. It’s whether you’ll do it in a way that respects who they are.
Looking Ahead: AR, VR, and Intelligent Journey Assistants
Agentic AI systems—AI that think and act autonomously—are on the rise, tackling open-ended tasks in real time.
Forrester
As personalization matures, the next evolution is poised to move toward immersion and assistance. Augmented and virtual reality will soon enable hyper-contextual experiences: virtual storefronts that adapt to your tastes, AR try-ons that adjust based on your body type, and AI stylists that remember your preferences across seasons.
Even more transformative is the rise of agentic AI—systems that not only generate content but act on behalf of the customer. These assistants will help plan purchases, anticipate needs, manage preferences, and even negotiate offers in real time.
Imagine a wellness assistant that knows your running schedule and suggests hydration supplements two days before your next long run. Or a retail companion that recommends outfits based on your upcoming calendar events and weather forecast.
These experiences will blend predictive awareness, real-time data, and generative capability—not just to sell, but to serve.
The Future Is Personal—and Responsible
The trajectory of personalization reflects both technical advancement and philosophical evolution. From merge tags to real-time assistants, the core promise has remained consistent: to be more relevant, more useful, and more human in how brands connect with people.
But that relevance must be earned, and that humanity must be protected. Brands that succeed will be those who invest not only in capability, but in consent, context, and care. Personalization is no longer a tool. It is the architecture of the modern customer relationship.
And if the trend lines hold, tomorrow’s personalization won’t just anticipate your needs. It will walk alongside you.
Related Martech Zone Content
