Marketing InfographicsSocial Media & Influencer Marketing

What’s the Impact of a Micro vs. Macro-Influencer Strategies on Instagram

Influencer marketing lies somewhere between the word-of-mouth colleague you trust and the paid advertisement you put on a website. Influencers often have the great ability to build awareness but range in their ability to influence prospects on a purchase decision. While it’s a more deliberate, engaging strategy to reach your core audience than a banner ad, influencer marketing continues to skyrocket in popularity.

However, there’s a conflict on whether your investment in influencer marketing is better spent as a large lump sum to a few superstars – the macro influencer, or whether your investment is better spent on more niche, highly focused influencers – the micro-influencers.

A large budget for a macro-influencer may fall flat and be a huge gamble. A large budget spent between micro-influencers may make it difficult to manage, coordinate, or build the impact you desire.

What is a Micro-Influencer?

I’d be classified as a micro-influencer. I have a niche focus on marketing technology and reach upwards of about 100,000 people via social, web, and email. My authority and popularity don’t extend beyond the focus of the content that I create; as a result, neither does the trust of my audience and the influence to make a purchase decision.

What is a Macro-Influencer?

Macro influencers have a much wider impact and personality. A well-known celebrity, journalist, or social media star can be macro-influencers (if they’re trusted and liked by their audience). Mediakix defines this segment about the medium:

  • A macro influencer on Instagram will generally have greater than 100,000 followers.
  • A macro influencer on YouTube or Facebook can be defined as having at least 250,000 subscribers or likes.

Mediakix analyzed over 700 sponsored Instagram posts from 16 top brands working with macro and micro influencers to assess which strategies were more effective.  They’ve produced this infographic, the Battle of the Influencers: Macro vs. Micro, and come to an interesting conclusion:

Our study shows that macro influencer and micro influencer performance is approximately equal when evaluating based solely on an engagement rate. Additionally, we found that macro influencers win out in terms of total likes, comments, and reach.

I contacted Jeremy Shih and asked the glaring question – return on investment (ROI). In other words, looking beyond engagement and likes, was there a measurable difference in key performance indicators like awareness, sales, upsells, etc. Jeremy responded honestly:

I can say that economies of scale are definitely at play here in the sense that it’s easier (less time and bandwidth intensive) to work with fewer, larger influencers than attempt to coordinate hundreds or thousands of smaller influencers to achieve the same reach. Furthermore, CPM tends to decrease as you work with larger influencers.

Jeremy Shih

Marketers must keep this in mind as they look to influencer marketing. While extensive coordination and a fantastic micro-influencer campaign might significantly impact the bottom line, the effort necessary may not be worth the investment in time and energy. As with anything in marketing, it’s worth testing and optimizing with your campaign strategies.

I think it’s also essential to remember that this was purely based on Instagram and not other mediums like blogging, podcasting, Facebook, Twitter, or LinkedIn. I believe a visual tool like Instagram could skew the results of an analysis like this significantly in the favor of the celebrity.

Micro vs Macro Influencers-more-effective-infographic
Credit: Source domain is no longer active.

Appreciate this content?

Sign up for our weekly newsletter, which delivers our latest posts every Monday morning.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Douglas Karr

Douglas Karr is a fractional Chief Marketing Officer specializing in SaaS and AI companies, where he helps scale marketing operations, drive demand generation, and implement AI-powered strategies. He is the founder and publisher of Martech Zone, a leading publication in marketing technology, and a trusted advisor to startups and enterprises alike. With a track record spanning more than $5 billion in MarTech acquisitions and investments, Douglas has led go-to-market strategy, brand positioning, and digital transformation initiatives for companies ranging from early-stage startups to global tech leaders like Dell, GoDaddy, Salesforce, Oracle, and Adobe. A published author of Corporate Blogging for Dummies and contributor to The Better Business Book, Douglas is also a recognized speaker, curriculum developer, and Forbes contributor. A U.S. Navy veteran, he combines strategic leadership with hands-on execution to help organizations achieve measurable growth.

Related Articles

Back to top button
Close

Adblock Detected

We rely on ads and sponsorships to keep Martech Zone free. Please consider disabling your ad blocker—or support us with an affordable, ad-free annual membership ($10 US):

Sign Up For An Annual Membership